In short: Without a decision, the administrator may only take minor or urgent measures (§ 27 WEG). Contracts that he concludes further bind the community; the administrator may then be liable for damages to the community. He may never, however, take out a loan without a decision. The community may not culpably breach its administrative duties and cause damage to a property owner; it may then claim damages from the community (§ 280, Para. 1 BGB i. v. m. § 18, Para. 2 WEG). If the administrator damages a property owner’s special property, he is liable directly to the owner.
The owners decide to have a repair carried out for 4,000 euros. In the end, bills totaling more than 18,000 euros are on the table, and the account is in the red. This is how a case was decided by the Federal Court of Justice in 2011, and in a similar way, many disputes between owners and their administrator begin. Who ultimately pays depends on what the administrator was allowed to do and what he was able to effectively agree upon externally. Both have changed significantly with the WEG reform, which came into effect on December 1, 2020.
Note: This is about the manager of a condominium association. Anyone who has commissioned a rental management company to manage their rented apartment will find the differences at the end of this article.
What can the administrator decide without a decision?
In the past, the law contained a whole catalog of tasks. Today, it works § SECTION 27 WEG with two open formulas. Without a decision, the administrator may and must take measures of proper administration that either
- have subordinate meaning and do not lead to significant obligations, or
- are necessary to comply with a deadline or to avoid a disadvantage.
What is „subordinate“ cannot be expressed in euros. It depends on the facility: In a large residential complex with high house dues, a repair request is routine; in a small complex with four parties, it would already be a significant expense. The legal justification lists as typical examples minor repairs, maintenance contracts, and gardening. Here too, the amount, duration, and scope are important. A ten-year maintenance contract is no longer a minor matter just because it’s called „maintenance.“.
Structural changes and expensive renovations are matters for the owners' meeting. If a water pipe bursts at night, the administrator does not have to call a meeting first. He can call the emergency services and contain the damage. The owners will then decide on the actual renovation.
Another matter is the implementation of decisions. This is always part of the manager’s responsibilities, regardless of the size of the project. If the owners have decided on a roof renovation costing 200,000 euros, the manager implements it without requiring any additional authority.
More powers through a decision
The owners can expand or narrow the scope (§ 27, paragraph 2 of the Land Use Act). If such a decision is made, the administrator does not need a new individual decision for measures within that scope. The Federal Court of Justice leaves a lot of leeway in this regard (Judgment of 05.07.2024 – V ZR 241/23In the decided case, the owners had decided that the windows needed to be replaced urgently, and had set a budget. The manager was free to choose which company would receive the order. This is permissible if the owners themselves have decided on the principle and the financing is secured.
The law does not stipulate any value limits per order and per year. Nevertheless, they are a good idea because they save both parties from disputes.
Should the community pay if the administrator goes too far?
Most of the time, yes. This surprises many owners, but it follows from a distinction that the law takes very seriously.
Desire and ability
Section 27 of the WEG regulates what the administrator must do in relation to the community. permission. Section 9b of the WEG regulates what he is to effectively do towards tradesmen, banks and other contractual partners. can. The second one goes much further than the first. A craftsman should be able to rely on the administrator acting on behalf of the community without having to read the decision-making collection beforehand.
After Article 9b, paragraph 1 of the WEG The administrator represents the community externally, and internal restrictions do not apply to third parties. If he commissions a contractor to carry out renovation work without a decision, the contract is therefore fundamentally valid, and the community must pay the bill. Otherwise, it can only be the case if the abuse was so obvious that the contractor had to recognize it.
An important exception is made by the law itself: a loan agreement can only be concluded by the trustee on behalf of the community based on a decision. The same applies to the purchase of a property.
| What the administrator does | Is the community bound? | What that means for the administrator |
|---|---|---|
| Minor repair, maintenance contract | Yes | Okay, as long as the amount, duration and scope remain within the limits and no decision states otherwise |
| Emergency measure following water damage | Yes | Okay, as far as was necessary to prevent damage |
| Expensive renovation without a decision | Usually yes | Violation of duty; compensation if the Community suffers damage |
| Credit within the framework of a decided credit limit | Yes | Okay, as long as the decision is followed |
| New loan in the name of the community without a decision | No, as long as the owners do not subsequently approve it | Can the bank itself be held liable against the bank, unless the bank knew or had to know that the decision was missing? |
What happens if the administrator finances costs through a loan?
Back to the case from the beginning. An administrator from the Cologne area handled the community’s payments through an account that was in his own name. The owners had decided to renovate the basement exterior wall for an estimated 4,000 euros. The administrator awarded further contracts. The bills totaled more than 18,000 euros; 14,802 of them he paid through the account in his own name, which thereby went into the red. When he was no longer the administrator, he demanded that the community release him from this deficit.
The Amtsgericht Siegburg ruled in his favor. The Court of Appeal in Cologne dismissed the lawsuit (judgment of 26 August 2010 – 29 S 177/09), and the Federal Court of Justice upheld it (Judgment of 18.02.2011 – V ZR 197/10). The administrator was not allowed to take out a loan without a decision. Because the account was in his name, he owed the bank the money himself. And the additional orders were not covered by the owners’ decision. The fact that he had informed the owners about the rising costs did not help him: Information does not replace a decision.
He could not rely on the other avenues through which one could possibly claim reimbursement for own expenses. An emergency that would have required immediate action did not exist; permanent remediation is not a measure of risk prevention. Nor was it apparent that the owners would have wanted the additional contracts if they had been asked. And regarding the question of whether the community had actually gained value from the work, the administrator had offered no explanation.
It is precisely this last point that can be the deciding factor. An administrator who does not pay for unfinished repairs does not always go without profit. If the community has actually gained value through the work, it can, depending on the circumstances, demand compensation (Supreme Court of the Federal Republic of Germany, judgment of 10.12.2021 – V ZR 32/21). The increase in value is generally decisive; if the owners had planned the measure anyway, the costs they have saved count. If the administrator acted against an express decision, he cannot rely on that to argue that he acted in the interests of the owners. The decision was made under the old law.
For property owners, this means: If the trustee pays for orders that no one has decided on through a loan, he may end up sitting on the costs entirely or partially. However, the community must possibly compensate him for what it has actually gained from the work. Whether a trustee will end up empty-handed even then, when he has decided The BGH explicitly left the measure with a pre-financing loan open to interpretation.
A bank account in the name of the trustee is today the exception for good reason. The community is itself legally capable, and its account should be in its name. Otherwise, the trustee is the account holder; the balance and debts are initially held with him, and the owners’ money is more difficult to separate from their own assets.
When is the administrator liable for damages?
If he culpably violates his obligations and the community thereby suffers a loss (§ 280, paragraph 1, BGB). He must also be held accountable for the errors of his employees. In practice, these situations usually arise:
- Contracts without a decision that go beyond his powers.
- Decisions that he does not implement, either late or in a different way than decided upon.
- Construction work that he did not properly supervise.
- Money problems: late billing, mixed accounts, arrears on household bills that no one seems to care about.
- Injured obligations to provide traffic safety, such as an unorganized winter service. If someone falls, the administrator may also be personally liable, in addition to the community.
In construction work, the Federal Court of Justice has specified the requirements in 2024 (Judgment of 26.01.2024 – V ZR 162/22). The manager must monitor maintenance measures like a builder would. Before paying a bill, he must check whether the work has been completed and whether the bill matches the contract and the progress of the construction. He must not overlook any defects that can be seen. Therefore, an architect is not required to be one. However, if he lacks the expertise in a large project, he should tell the owners and suggest commissioning a skilled construction supervision.
Damage does not automatically occur. If the administrator has arbitrarily commissioned a repair that was in any case necessary and carried out at a fair price, there is often no damage for which one could claim compensation.
Claims generally expire after three years. The deadline begins at the end of the year in which the claim arose and the community learned about it or would have had to have learned about it without gross negligence (§§ 195, 199 BGB).
The community does not act through the administrator itself; that would be absurd. It is represented by the chairman of the administrative council or by an owner who has been authorized by the assembly to do so (§ 9b, paragraph 2 of the WEG). Therefore, anyone who wants to assert claims first needs a corresponding decision.
Can I sue the administrator myself as the owner?
Not in the administrator agreement. The Federal Court of Justice clarified this in 2024 (Judgment of 05.07.2024 – V ZR 34/24). The contract is concluded only by the community and the administrator; since the reform, the administrator no longer protects the individual owners directly. The community is their contact person. It owes each owner proper administration and must accept responsibility for the administrator’s errors. If the community culpably breaches its administrative obligations and causes damage to an owner as a result, it may demand compensation from it (§ 280, paragraph 1, BGB i.v.m. § 18, paragraph 2, WEG).
The BGH has explicitly left one door open in this regard: If the administrator damages your special property, he will still be liable to you directly for unlawful conduct (§ 823 BGB).
For everything else, the way forward is through the community, which can then take action through the administrator. If the majority does not agree to this, a property owner can sue to have the decision replaced (§ 44, paragraph 1, sentence 2 of the WEG).
How does the community protect itself?
Clarity beforehand is most effective. A decision under § 27(2) of the WEG, which sets out a budget, award rules and, where applicable, value limits, prevents most disputes.
If it turns out during a decided measure that additional work is necessary, it depends on whether the previous decision covers it. If it does not, and the work can wait without further damage being threatened, a notice from the administrator is not sufficient. The owners must decide again, if necessary in an extraordinary meeting. On the other hand, if immediate action is needed to avert further damage, the administrator may immediately initiate the urgently required work (§ 27, paragraph 1, no. 2 of the WEG).
Caution is warranted when granting discharge. A discharge resolution can exclude claims for compensation that were known or apparent during the vote. Those who have doubts about the administration should not routinely vote in favor.
Since December 1st, 2023, any owner can also request that a certified administrator be appointed (§ 26a WEG). This is proof of specific expertise, such as through an IHK examination or a comparable qualification. For small communities with fewer than nine units where one owner manages them personally, an exception applies as long as at least one third of the owners request a certified administrator.
If trust no longer exists, the owners can recall the administrator at any time. There is no longer any need for a specific reason since the reform. The administrator contract ends at the latest six months after recall (§ 26, paragraph 3 of the WEG). Before switching, ensure you have records, a collection of decisions, bank statements and contracts. The administrator himself/herself can also leave; for that see our article. Can a house manager resign from their position at any time?
What applies to rental management?
Many landlords have their apartments managed by a property management company that collects rent, undertakes repairs, and takes care of the tenants. This type of rental management is not governed by the WEG, but by the contract between the owner and the management company.
What the administration is allowed to do is set out in the contract and in the power of attorney. If it goes beyond that, the contract with the tradesperson or tenant is initially in limbo until the owner approves it (§ 177 BGB). If the owner does not approve it, the administration may hold the contractual partner personally liable, unless the latter knew or should have known that the power of attorney was insufficient (§ 179 BGB). Unlike in the WEG, the owner can directly claim damages from his administration here, because he is their contractual partner.
When a tenant could pay to a administration with liberating effect, whose authority was questionable, our contribution to the case is treated as follows: Power of attorney for payment of rent to a property manager.
Frequently asked questions
What can a WEG administrator do without a decision?
Minor measures that do not lead to significant obligations and everything necessary to meet a deadline or to prevent damage (§ 27, paragraph 1 of the WEG). If the owners have delegated additional tasks to him through a decision, he may also act alone in this context.
Must the community pay for an order that the administrator has issued without a decision?
As a rule, yes, because the administrator effectively represents them externally. If this has caused them any damage, they can demand that the administrator compensate them.
Can the trustee finance costs through a loan?
Not without a decision. If he takes out the loan from his own account, he owes it to the bank himself. In the case decided by the BGH in 2011, the trustee also received nothing back from the community because the paid-for work had not been approved and he had not demonstrated any value added to the community. If the community has actually gained value from the work, depending on the circumstances, it may be entitled to compensation.
Can I demand compensation from the administrator directly as the owner?
Not from the management contract. If the community culpably breaches its administrative obligations and causes damage to an owner as a result, they can claim damages from it (§ 280, paragraph 1, BGB i.v.m. § 18, paragraph 2, WEG). However, if the manager damages your special property, you can still claim it directly.
Who represents the community in relation to the administrator?
The chairman of the administrative council or an owner who the assembly has authorized to do so by resolution (§ 9b, paragraph 2 of the WEG).
How quickly can a trustee be recalled?
At any time by decision, without a valid reason. The administrator contract ends at the latest six months later.
Dispute with the administrator about unauthorized expenses?
Send us the management contract, the decisions in question, and the disputed invoices. We will tell you whether the manager has exceeded his authority, whether the community is bound by the contracts, and what claims exist.
Telephone: 0221 - 80187670
E-Mail: info@mth-partner.de
Author: Lawyer Helmer Tieben, MIntTax (University of Melbourne); admitted as a lawyer since 2005, Cologne Bar Association. Office address: Sachsenring 34, 50677 Cologne.
Jurisdiction: November 2026, including the WEG reform, in effect since December 1, 2020.
Important Note: The content of this article has been prepared to the best of our knowledge and belief. However, due to the complexity and constant evolution of the subject matter, we must exclude liability and warranty. Important Notice: The content of this article has been created to the best of our knowledge and understanding. However, due to the complexity and constant changes in the subject matter, we must exclude any liability and warranty.


